Not a Love Letter.
that I was just like the sort of girl you've kind of always wanted.
Well, let me be the one to succumb to vulnerability
(slash: idealism, slash: unfounded reverie) and say:
You are everything I've always sought.
Until now, I've never written about you.
(And god, does that speak volumes.)
Some part of me denied that this was even happening,
didn't want to admit what was going on,
because, as I've always said:
You are going to leave me with so much baggage.
But the truth is:
This is real.
This is happening.
This is terrifying,
but such is life.
There have been so many surreal moments together
that I've wanted to freeze, to pause, to preserve forever.
Your rambling, reserved confession was one of them.
Because in that lacking, in that state of "almost",
everything was immediately confirmed.
People with nothing to contemplate and less to lose
are always throwing around equally empty and extreme declarations.
Clearly uninvested in what they have and say,
they haven't felt the agonizing fear of what it means to get 'too close.'
Which is why exactly why
I adore how frightened you are when it comes to this.
I appreciate the mixed signals and backhanded compliments all the more.
Trust me, every second I spend with you is wrecked with horrifying terror;
it's not like I don't sympathize.
It's just that there comes a moment when you have to risk everything
for the chance at merely... something,
and this something is worth that risk for me.
We have a title, as far as people know, but I don't care for it.
We are lesbians and swingers and addicts and children.
We are musicians and abusers and brothers and sisters.
We are anything but heterosexual and nothing like the norm.
But if we seem, to the world, like any other "couple",
so be it.
Because I know how insanely unique this is.
I don't think 'love' even applies here.
It's the first word that comes to mind.
It's the easy, obvious, cliché expression.
& Yes, it's the verb that I most often articulate.
But when I say such things, I'm not telling you the half of it.
"Love" has never met us, and it doesn't comprehend.
"Love" is far too old, too tired, too misused to understand.
"Love" says nothing of the fact that:
You're the best friend I've ever hoped to have.
It has no indication of:
the perpetual admiration,
the unbelievable gratitude,
the sheer awe,
the utter ecstasy,
the bittersweet addiction.
It isn't storybook.
& As you know: it wasn't immediate.
Let's just say it:
You were desperate & I was a whore.
We shared one single night,
and I half-expected
to never hear from you again.
Then something (really, everything) began to change.
We grew into something I couldn't understand or believe.
Slowly and surprisingly, "casual" became committed.
Undeniably, and unintentionally, ritual was redefined.
Now, months later, something in me has registered:
You are, for all intents and purpose, beyond perfect.
And for all of your flaws, and all of mine,
so are we.
Not in spite, but in credit.
(No. It doesn't make sense to me either.)
& The truth is, it's not supposed to.
I'm 20 years old, and I have haphazardly met
the person who has made me happier
than I ever intend to be again.
What could be less practical than that?
Like you, I never wanted this.
I condemned monogamy,
gave up on commitment,
reserved myself to misandry entire.
But I have day-/night-dreams of rings now
and to be brutally and unwillingly honest:
maybe this has nothing to do with you at all.
Maybe you really are just a picture, a memory, a notch on my bedpost.
I want to doubt that, and I do, but admitting such a thing seems so final.
I feel like I have to be intangible for you to want me,
and I guess this is all some elaborate game
to mask how much, how happily I've lost.
You've studied more poetry than I can really imagine.
And I don't want you to take this as a formal attempt.
Because I know you'll find it cheap and sacrilegious.
I just want you to understand that THIS IS ME.
I am informal, uncultured, stream-of-consciousness
and quite possibly entirely wrong for you.
But I want you more than I have confidence to say.
& This is the only way I can hope to express such things.
(By being cynical and hurtful and ironic, I know....
Isn't life a mindfuck?)
Call it pessimism,
Call it realism,
but something tells me you'll end up in a box of mine
well before a coffin of your own.
I imagine we'll split decades before we die.
It's safe to say that we'll never have the adventures we've planned
in Amsterdam, Paris, Rome, Kathmandu.
Having thought I've found the one,
I'll likely end up looking again.
Maybe this is indulgent self-sabotage.
Maybe this is menacing reverse psychology.
Maybe this is that unnameable paranoia that only comes
when you realize that you have everything
and thus, everything to lose.
But I hate what you have done to me,
and I will never forgive you for this--
because you've broken down all of my defenses,
you've destroyed my carefully-constructed isolation,
you've caused me to live in perpetual fear.
& I have never, ever been happier.


